YPAS ‘Ragtime’ debate follows many since first school production in 2004

Clamor in Louisville reflects larger debates over themes in school theater, the arts
By Oakland Pizzolato, Arts Angle Reporter
Atherton High School, Class of 2027
On a Friday at duPont Manual High School in early November, two weeks remained before the opening of the musical “Ragtime.” This production received a deluge of publicity in August when the school administrators abruptly canceled it. That lasted less than 24 hours before the public outcry reversed that decision.
But on this fall day, a group gathered in the high school gym for a forum Jefferson County Public Schools called “Clearing the Air.” It included school staff, administrators, some community members, students, and cast members.
Louisville Youth Performing Arts School's forum, called "Cleaning the Air," as reported by Manual High School's Manual RedEye.
One was Jeremiah Stephens, a Manual High School senior in its Youth Performing Arts School who plays Coalhouse Walker Jr in the musical. Like some others, the threat of cancellation raised worries about censorship and artistic freedoms.
“At the heart of what we do here at the Youth Performing Arts School is truthful storytelling,” Stephens said. “I think to do this show and then to censor it removes — or it doesn't aim for the purpose [of why] we're doing this show.”
The August 26 post from the Instagram account created by YPAS "Ragtime" cast members after they learned the musical was being cancelled.
JCPS directed Arts Angle declined media requests for interviews and to attend a “Ragtime” rehearsal, citing scrutiny around the production. Cast members contacted never returned Arts Angle's emails or texts.
The musical, adapted from E.L. Doctorow’s award-winning 1975 novel, premiered on Broadway in 1998 to positive reviews from critics praising the Broadway production as one of the era’s most significant musicals. The musical, with music by Stephen Flaherty, lyrics by Lynn Ahrens, and a book by Terrence McNally, earned four Tony Awards, and the 2026 revival also scored favorable reviews and four Tony Awards.
“Ragtime” combines early New York City 20th-century fictional and historical figures. Built around three stories taking place in early 1900s New York, the story follows an upper class white family struggling in their traditional roles. Jewish immigrant Tateh and his daughter are seeking a better life in America, and Coalhouse Walker Jr., a Black pianist, seeking justice after a racist attack. Many historical figures appear in addition to these characters as this musical explores racism, immigration, class divisions, political violence, and the gap between America’s ideals and the realities citizens experience.

E.L. Doctorow in 2008 and the cover of his 1975 novel "Ragtime."
Despite a long history, debates surrounding “Ragtime” are not new. Many find these controversies particularly surprising considering the musical's history of critical acclaim and success — not only on Broadway but in high schools.
Just as the novel “Ragtime” debuted in a year of monumental changes in the country with the end of the Vietnam War, the Watergate scandal, and the resignation of President Richard Nixon, the Broadway revival and the YPAS production of the musical come at a time of a shifting political climate. Recent election results and the Democratic “blue wave” give new context to conversations around “Ragtime.” With issues such as immigration playing a large role in political discourse, many themes explored in the musical now have new relevance. While Louisville ranks near the middle of major U.S. cities in foreign-born population, the city has also faced its own struggles over race and inequality in recent years, making the musical’s themes resonate locally. These factors have played into local debates and across the country.
The country didn’t seem as tumultuous in 2004 when “Ragtime” was making its way to a high school stage. Music Theatre International, the New York-based licensing agency, approached Long Island’s Baldwin Senior High School to perform a school edition of “Ragtime” because of its reputation for strong musical productions, according to The Freeport Baldwin Leader’s Dec. 2, 2004, edition. The show’s original writers and producers adapted it for high school performers. The production demonstrated that educators had faith that their students were capable of performing meaningful productions centered around difficult themes.

The article about the innauguural high shcool production of "Ragtime" by Long Island’s Baldwin Senior High School in The Freeport Baldwin Leader’s Dec. 2, 2004, issue.
These same themes would put the show at the center of later debates in different communities across the country.
In 2017, New Jersey’s Cherry Hill High School East was at the center of a debate after district officials considered changing the musical’s script to remove racial slurs. According to a Jan. 27, 2017, post from the National Coalition Against Censorship, community members and advocates believed that changing the musical’s language would erase context. The district ultimately decided to perform the musical as written while hosting community conversations about the production. Musical Theatre International later gave the school its Courage in Theatre award, praising the students and school leaders for tackling the difficult conversations instead of avoiding them.
Other administrations took different actions when schools planned to perform "Ragtime."
In 2008, a district in Chicago cancelled a production after Music Theatre International refused their request to change the severe racial slur in the script, and a in 2015, a Minnesota high school suggested changing the script when it faced an outcry, according to a Philadelphia Inquirer article reporting on activities at New Jersey’s Cherry Hill High School East.
“Ragtime” gives audiences the chance to talk and reflect upon topics with historical context. That’s according to the Educational Theatre Association, a group that supports school theater programs. It issued a statement after the Jefferson County Public Schools canceled the musical and before it reversed its decision.
“We felt it was important to speak up when students’ work and access to a theater experience appeared to be at risk,” said Zach Dulli with EdTA.
The association argued that the difficult material can be handled thoughtfully and educationally and noted productions that tackle race, identity, and representation often arise because they bring up painful or contested parts of history.
“Theater education can help students examine those subjects with context, guidance, and care,” Dulli stressed.
Similarly to Cherry Hill High School East, the Nov. 6 forum at YPAS, JCPS organized a forum to address the community and its concerns surrounding the controversy and show. Present among students and faculty involved with the production was Brian Yearwood, Jefferson County Public Schools’ first Black superintendent.
The Nov. 20 post from the Instagram account created by YPAS "Ragtime" cast members the same day they approach opening night of "Ragtime."
“I am encouraged to see that everyone here tonight, everyone is gathered to explore “Ragtime”’s themes, its history, and its message,” Yearwood said.
Even as the curtain rises on YPAS’s production of “Ragtime,” preparations are already underway for another in Southern Indiana. Floyd Central and New Albany High schools announced in May the two theater programs are uniting to stage “Ragtime” March 5 through 14 at New Albany High School. The schools held auditions for child actors on Thursday.
This string of productions illustrate this musical, while sometimes labeled controversial, is largely celebrated.
The debates surrounding “Ragtime” in Louisville may have centered around a local school production, but it raised questions and discussions that extended beyond Louisville.
“That's important,” Yearwood said. “This is exactly the kind of dialogue that the arts should inspire.”




Comments